[OPT-6200] Definition Selection fails resolving tenants on multi-engine scenario

Type: Bug Report
Resolution: Fixed
Priority: L3 - Default
Fix Version/s: 3.8.3, 3.9.0-preview-1
Affects Version/s: 3.1.0, 3.2.0, 3.3.0, 3.4.0, 3.5.0, 3.6.0, 3.7.0, 3.8.0
Component/s: backend
Labels:
None

Effort:
Not defined

Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Scenario:
User exists in engine 1
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1
No tenants exist on engine1
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1 with no tenant set

User exists in engine 2
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2
User has all process definition authorization in engine 2
No tenants exist on engine2
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2 with no tenant set

Given the following Optimize config:

engines:
  'camunda-bpm-1':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm1
      name: cambpm1
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}'
      enabled: true
  'camunda-bpm-2':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm2
      name: cambpm2
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}'

Steps to reproduce:

Login to Optimize with User
Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess`

Actual result:

3. An authorization error is thrown:

Expected result:

As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

This is the controller panel for Smart Panels app

- - Sort By Name
  - Sort By Date
  - Ascending
  - Descending
  - Thumbnails
  - List
  - Download All

image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png
171 kB
11/May/22 5:00 PM

Sebastian Bathke created issue - 11/May/22 5:00 PM

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:00 PM

Labels

New: current_release

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:00 PM

Attachment		New: image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png [ 51933 ]
Description	Original: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ? Scenario: User exists in engine 1 User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1 A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1 User exists in engine 2 User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2 User has all process definition authorization in engine 2 A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2 Given the following Optimize config: {code:java} engines: 'camunda-bpm-1': name: default defaultTenant: id: cambpm1 name: cambpm1 rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}' importEnabled: true authentication: enabled: false password: '' user: '' webapps: endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}' enabled: true 'camunda-bpm-2': name: default defaultTenant: id: cambpm2 name: cambpm2 rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}' importEnabled: true authentication: enabled: false password: '' user: '' webapps: endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code} h2. Steps to reproduce: # Login to Optimize # Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess` h3. Actual result: 3. An authorization error is thrown: !image-2022-05-11-17-00-22-057.png! h3. Expected result: As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2	New: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ? Scenario: User exists in engine 1 User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1 A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1 User exists in engine 2 User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2 User has all process definition authorization in engine 2 A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2 Given the following Optimize config: {code:java} engines: 'camunda-bpm-1': name: default defaultTenant: id: cambpm1 name: cambpm1 rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}' importEnabled: true authentication: enabled: false password: '' user: '' webapps: endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}' enabled: true 'camunda-bpm-2': name: default defaultTenant: id: cambpm2 name: cambpm2 rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}' importEnabled: true authentication: enabled: false password: '' user: '' webapps: endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code} h2. Steps to reproduce: # Login to Optimize # Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess` h3. Actual result: 3. An authorization error is thrown: !image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png! h3. Expected result: As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:01 PM

Description

Original: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Scenario:
User exists in engine 1
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1

User exists in engine 2
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2
User has all process definition authorization in engine 2
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2
Given the following Optimize config:
{code:java}
engines:
  'camunda-bpm-1':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm1
      name: cambpm1
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}'
      enabled: true
  'camunda-bpm-2':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm2
      name: cambpm2
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code}
h2. Steps to reproduce:
# Login to Optimize
# Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess`

h3. Actual result:

3. An authorization error is thrown:
!image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png!
h3. Expected result:

As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

New: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Scenario:
User exists in engine 1
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1

User exists in engine 2
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2
User has all process definition authorization in engine 2
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2
Given the following Optimize config:
{code:java}
engines:
  'camunda-bpm-1':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm1
      name: cambpm1
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}'
      enabled: true
  'camunda-bpm-2':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm2
      name: cambpm2
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code}
h2. Steps to reproduce:
# Login to Optimize
# Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess`

h3. Actual result:

3. An authorization error is thrown:
!image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png|width=751,height=484!
h3. Expected result:

As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:01 PM

Description

Original: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Scenario:
User exists in engine 1
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1

User exists in engine 2
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2
User has all process definition authorization in engine 2
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2
Given the following Optimize config:
{code:java}
engines:
  'camunda-bpm-1':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm1
      name: cambpm1
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}'
      enabled: true
  'camunda-bpm-2':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm2
      name: cambpm2
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code}
h2. Steps to reproduce:
# Login to Optimize
# Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess`

h3. Actual result:

3. An authorization error is thrown:
!image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png|width=751,height=484!
h3. Expected result:

As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

New: h2. Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Scenario:
User exists in engine 1
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 1
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 1

User exists in engine 2
User has Optimize application authorization in engine 2
User has all process definition authorization in engine 2
A process with key "testProcess" is deployed to engine 2
Given the following Optimize config:
{code:java}
engines:
  'camunda-bpm-1':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm1
      name: cambpm1
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_1:http://localhost:8080/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8080/camunda}'
      enabled: true
  'camunda-bpm-2':
    name: default
    defaultTenant:
      id: cambpm2
      name: cambpm2
    rest: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_REST_URL_2:http://localhost:8081/engine-rest}'
    importEnabled: true
    authentication:
      enabled: false
      password: ''
      user: ''
    webapps:
      endpoint: '${OPTIMIZE_CAMUNDABPM_WEBAPPS_URL:http://localhost:8081/camunda}' {code}
h2. Steps to reproduce:
# Login to Optimize with User
# Try to create a report and select the definition `testProcess`

h3. Actual result:

3. An authorization error is thrown:
!image-2022-05-11-17-00-41-103.png|width=751,height=484!
h3. Expected result:

As the user has access to the definition on engine-2, the process selection should succeed, using the default tenant for engine-2

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:05 PM

Affects Version/s

New: 3.8.0 [ 17435 ]

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:06 PM

Summary

Original: Definition Selection fails resolving tenants

New: Definition Selection fails resolving tenants on multi-engine setup

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:09 PM

Affects Version/s

New: 3.7.0 [ 16990 ]

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:22 PM

Affects Version/s

New: 3.6.0 [ 16894 ]

Sebastian Bathke made changes - 11/May/22 5:38 PM

Affects Version/s

New: 3.5.0 [ 16724 ]

Assignee:: Unassigned

Reporter:: Sebastian Bathke

Votes:: 0 Vote for this issue

Watchers:: 1 Start watching this issue

Created:: 11/May/22 5:00 PM

Updated:: 01/Aug/22 5:04 PM

Resolved:: 31/May/22 12:55 PM

Details

Description

Brief summary of the bug. What is it ? Where is it ?

Steps to reproduce:

Actual result:

Expected result:

mgm-controller-panel

This is the controller panel for Smart Panels app

Attachments

Attachments

Activity

People

Dates

Salesforce