Uploaded image for project: 'camunda BPM'
  1. camunda BPM
  2. CAM-13137 I can set variables when performing process instance migration
  3. CAM-13406

Evaluate if variables should already be set in the source process instance

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Sub-task
    • Resolution: Done
    • L3 - Default
    • 7.16.0, 7.16.0-alpha1
    • None
    • None
    • None

    Description

      Context

      The overall goal of the feature is to set a variable to the global scope of the migrated process instance so that execution can continue without a further manual intervention like setting variables afterward.

      However, there are two ways of achieving this:

      • Set the variable before the process instance is migrated (variable is set to the old and migrated to the new process instance)
      • Set the variable after the process instance is migrated (variable is set to the new process instance)

      To be evaluated design decision: The variable is set before the process instance is migrated

      Pros
      I can execute my listeners or IO mappings because the variables they require are set before the migration

      Cons

      • Setting a variable before migration could trigger unwanted execution behavior, e.g., a conditional event listens to this variable and triggers before the migration takes place, which already changes the process instance state based on the old process definition
        • Maybe we can prevent this since it is unwanted execution behavior that shouldn't be triggered during a user operation
      • The main use-case is to make process instances work after the migration since the data model between the process definitions is different and not to make IO Mappings and listeners succeed

      To be evaluated design decision: I can configure whether a variable is set before or after the process instance is migrated

      Pros

      • The feature is more powerful
      • If the use-case becomes more pressing, we already have a nice API and don't need to wrangle distinguishing setting a variable before or after in the already existing API

      Cons

      • We have no proof that users actually want to set the variable before migrating the process instance
      • Extra effort in implementing (preventing state change of process instance when setting a variable before process instance migration), writing tests, and documenting the feature
      • Users might wonder which way of setting the variable is the best one => might lead to confusion

      Reasoning & Design Decision

      The use-case for setting variables before the process instance migration might be a bit artificial. We don't know if users would benefit from it, which does not really justify the extra effort. Also, I currently cannot oversee the problems that might emerge revolving around triggering unwanted execution behavior when setting a variable before process instance migration. If required, we can still add a flag in the future to control whether variables are set before or after the process instance migration, which might result in a slightly less user-friendly but acceptable API.

      mgm-controller-panel

        This is the controller panel for Smart Panels app

        Attachments

          Activity

            People

              tassilo.weidner Tassilo Weidner
              tassilo.weidner Tassilo Weidner
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              1 Start watching this issue

              Dates

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved:

                Salesforce