Uploaded image for project: 'camunda BPM'
  1. camunda BPM
  2. CAM-4897

What happens if the DMN file does not contain IDs

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Task Task
    • Resolution: Done
    • Icon: L3 - Default L3 - Default
    • None
    • None
    • dmn-engine, dmn-ui
    • None

      Lets assume someone deployes a DMN file without IDs, which is valid. What happens next?

        This is the controller panel for Smart Panels app

            [CAM-4897] What happens if the DMN file does not contain IDs

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment -

            The UI does not need ids. Display of a table without ids works fine. Modeling will generate ids for new elements (already existing elements do not automatically get ids).

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment - The UI does not need ids. Display of a table without ids works fine. Modeling will generate ids for new elements (already existing elements do not automatically get ids).

            Sebastian Menski added a comment -

            And the history view? What happens if the input, output and rules don't have ids? I'm currently not sure if the backend can even handle this.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment - And the history view? What happens if the input, output and rules don't have ids? I'm currently not sure if the backend can even handle this.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment -

            We decided that the DMN Engine will require IDs on Decisions, Clauses and Rules for now.

            @sebastian.stamm has anything to be checked in the frontend/modeler? Otherwise we can close this ticket.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment - We decided that the DMN Engine will require IDs on Decisions, Clauses and Rules for now. @ sebastian.stamm has anything to be checked in the frontend/modeler? Otherwise we can close this ticket.

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment -

            When the user imports a table without ids, it will also be exported without ids (it will not be automatically repaired). If this is okay for now, we can close the ticket.

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment - When the user imports a table without ids, it will also be exported without ids (it will not be automatically repaired). If this is okay for now, we can close the ticket.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment -

            Yeah I think this is the expected behavior. Important is that the modeler adds IDs on a newly created DMN file.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment - Yeah I think this is the expected behavior. Important is that the modeler adds IDs on a newly created DMN file.

            Sebastian Menski added a comment -

            Result: Currently we enforce IDs in the backend

            Sebastian Menski added a comment - Result: Currently we enforce IDs in the backend

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment -

            Newly created tables always have ids.

            Sebastian Stamm added a comment - Newly created tables always have ids.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              sebastian.menski Sebastian Menski
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              2 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: